Last night was refreshing on many levels. We all believe in community, but the endless question nagging us at the back of our minds remains, "How do we flesh it out?" Last night we went out to eat, left the notes, books, theories behind and just enjoyed each other. I dedicated the night to Jen, who needs to be reminded that she is more important than any lesson ever could be and that we will be there for her, even if it is in small ways like going out to eat instead of studying together. I hope we are learning at a grassroots level how to be the answer to prayer. This is it, right here.
Shirts: let's go out next Monday and pick them up (before we go to Heather's) ready to give to Tony and hopefully have them returned Tuesday night!!!
"Brian does Magic!" (to Eaglet)
Wednesday, August 29, 2007
Tuesday, August 28, 2007
Temple- Action
Mark’s Gospel to Rome
“An expository look into the text”
VI. Finally in Jerusalem
I. The Importance of the Temple-Action
The symbolic action of cleansing the Temple, the most important Jewish symbol of the
day, should not be seen as an attempt at reform but at an acted symbol of judgment. This goes back many generations of the belief in what the Messiah would do: cleanse/ rebuild the temple and bring back YHWH’s rule. In this context is where we see Jesus as a Messiah- to be seen as such before the resurrection, although this helped confirm all that the Messiah had already done.
Let’s dive further, now, into the Temple-action (Mk 11:15-17). We know that earlier that week (referred to as Holy Week) Jesus’s triumphal entry into Jerusalem set the stage for royalty and messiahship undertones- it would have been seen next to the recent Maccabean entry where palm branches were waved as Judas had defeated the pagans and cleansed the temple… sorta. Jesus entered as a Messiah in the politically crazed city during the week before Passover which had Jews hungry for the end of exile= beating Rome out of their promised land. Roman soldiers filled the streets ready for revolts. Sacarii were busy in back alleys murdering Romans. Jewish pilgrims were flocking to the city for the festivals. The priests were reaping from the sacrifices and readying for the most important day for the Temple: Passover. Thus, the temple-action and the Last Supper are seen closely tied together. We will look at the Last Supper next week. This is our context for seeing the cleansing of the Temple.
It is a very symbolic action, but does not stand alone in its importance. Wright puts it “Jesus’s messianic Temple- action is surrounded with several sayings that function, as it were, as royal riddles, explaining, sometimes cryptically, the meaning of what had just happened (Challenge of Jesus 77).” 3 sayings include- Mk 11:27-12:12, and 35-37.
Authority Q: What right does he have to act in this messianic fashion, and from whom does he get the authority?
A: What do you think of John the Baptist?
Jesus refers to John as the last great prophet, the Elijah who is to come. So if John is Elijah… Jesus must be at least Messiah with hints towards his baptism by John where he was anointed with the Spirit (Truth)--- when he became the anointed one, Messiah.
Rejected Prophet Parables: The story of the Wicked Tenants is precisely the story about a line of rejected prophets, culminating in the rejected Son. Judgment upon the city and Temple which have rejected Jesus. This serves as a further explanation to the temple-action.
This parable runs straight into the picture of the son and stone: “The stone which the builders rejected has become the head of the corner.” This is a quote from Ps 118, a pilgrim passage about building the Temple, celebrating and finally sacrificing in the Temple. Jesus claims to be building the eschatological Temple in and through himself. (see Daniel 2 and Challenge of Jesus 78 for more info). So, the story of the rejected servants climaxes in the rejected son; he, however, is the messianic “stone” that, rejected by the builders, takes the chief place in the building (Temple). Those who oppose him will find their regime and Temple destroyed, while His kingdom will be established. (Mk 13).
David’s Son/Lord? How, he asks, can the Messiah be David’s son, when according to Psalm 110 he is also David’s Lord? (This is not his denial of messiahship). It is actually a redefinition of what Davidic messiahship means- his challenge about a warrior king that was expected. Further it is twofold answer: The psalm goes on to say that a king is also “a priest for ever, after the order of Melchizedek”; implying he has authority over the Temple. Secondly, the one enthroned acts as judge. Jesus is again affirming is right to announce doom on Temple and ruling elite. By the way he forms the question, Jesus is “both cryptically affirming his claim to be David’s true son and also pointing to the larger claim, that he carries the authority of David’s Lord.”
Here we see the Temple-action as highly messianic. Jesus both knew what he was doing and saw himself as Messiah long before this day (perhaps at the Baptism). It is concluded in the trial scene where Caiaphas asks Jesus about the Temple with no reply from Jesus. Then the direct question whether he is the Messiah- the obvious next question when seen as the nexus for all that Jesus had done, intentionally, as messiah! Jesus’s answer is to be seen as a yes with a double biblical quotation coming from the messianic chapters Ps 110 and Daniel 7. “You will see the Son of Man sitting at the right hand of Power, and coming in the clouds of heaven.” In other words, as Wright puts it, Caiaphas will witness Jesus’s vindication in the events following Jesus’s death and in the judgment that will fall upon his regime and its central symbol. This explains his thoughts of himself as Messiah, what his intentions in the Temple and riddles surrounding it were, why it was so easy for the chief priests to arrest him as a rebel king and how Pilate came to crucify Jesus with the words “King of the Jews” written above his head. Finally, it helps us see why his disciples regarded him as Messiah after the resurrection. The Temple did not stand alone in it’s meaning- the riddles around it help us understand all that he was doing. Next week we will see what the deal is with the Last Supper!
“An expository look into the text”
VI. Finally in Jerusalem
I. The Importance of the Temple-Action
The symbolic action of cleansing the Temple, the most important Jewish symbol of the
day, should not be seen as an attempt at reform but at an acted symbol of judgment. This goes back many generations of the belief in what the Messiah would do: cleanse/ rebuild the temple and bring back YHWH’s rule. In this context is where we see Jesus as a Messiah- to be seen as such before the resurrection, although this helped confirm all that the Messiah had already done.
Let’s dive further, now, into the Temple-action (Mk 11:15-17). We know that earlier that week (referred to as Holy Week) Jesus’s triumphal entry into Jerusalem set the stage for royalty and messiahship undertones- it would have been seen next to the recent Maccabean entry where palm branches were waved as Judas had defeated the pagans and cleansed the temple… sorta. Jesus entered as a Messiah in the politically crazed city during the week before Passover which had Jews hungry for the end of exile= beating Rome out of their promised land. Roman soldiers filled the streets ready for revolts. Sacarii were busy in back alleys murdering Romans. Jewish pilgrims were flocking to the city for the festivals. The priests were reaping from the sacrifices and readying for the most important day for the Temple: Passover. Thus, the temple-action and the Last Supper are seen closely tied together. We will look at the Last Supper next week. This is our context for seeing the cleansing of the Temple.
It is a very symbolic action, but does not stand alone in its importance. Wright puts it “Jesus’s messianic Temple- action is surrounded with several sayings that function, as it were, as royal riddles, explaining, sometimes cryptically, the meaning of what had just happened (Challenge of Jesus 77).” 3 sayings include- Mk 11:27-12:12, and 35-37.
Authority Q: What right does he have to act in this messianic fashion, and from whom does he get the authority?
A: What do you think of John the Baptist?
Jesus refers to John as the last great prophet, the Elijah who is to come. So if John is Elijah… Jesus must be at least Messiah with hints towards his baptism by John where he was anointed with the Spirit (Truth)--- when he became the anointed one, Messiah.
Rejected Prophet Parables: The story of the Wicked Tenants is precisely the story about a line of rejected prophets, culminating in the rejected Son. Judgment upon the city and Temple which have rejected Jesus. This serves as a further explanation to the temple-action.
This parable runs straight into the picture of the son and stone: “The stone which the builders rejected has become the head of the corner.” This is a quote from Ps 118, a pilgrim passage about building the Temple, celebrating and finally sacrificing in the Temple. Jesus claims to be building the eschatological Temple in and through himself. (see Daniel 2 and Challenge of Jesus 78 for more info). So, the story of the rejected servants climaxes in the rejected son; he, however, is the messianic “stone” that, rejected by the builders, takes the chief place in the building (Temple). Those who oppose him will find their regime and Temple destroyed, while His kingdom will be established. (Mk 13).
David’s Son/Lord? How, he asks, can the Messiah be David’s son, when according to Psalm 110 he is also David’s Lord? (This is not his denial of messiahship). It is actually a redefinition of what Davidic messiahship means- his challenge about a warrior king that was expected. Further it is twofold answer: The psalm goes on to say that a king is also “a priest for ever, after the order of Melchizedek”; implying he has authority over the Temple. Secondly, the one enthroned acts as judge. Jesus is again affirming is right to announce doom on Temple and ruling elite. By the way he forms the question, Jesus is “both cryptically affirming his claim to be David’s true son and also pointing to the larger claim, that he carries the authority of David’s Lord.”
Here we see the Temple-action as highly messianic. Jesus both knew what he was doing and saw himself as Messiah long before this day (perhaps at the Baptism). It is concluded in the trial scene where Caiaphas asks Jesus about the Temple with no reply from Jesus. Then the direct question whether he is the Messiah- the obvious next question when seen as the nexus for all that Jesus had done, intentionally, as messiah! Jesus’s answer is to be seen as a yes with a double biblical quotation coming from the messianic chapters Ps 110 and Daniel 7. “You will see the Son of Man sitting at the right hand of Power, and coming in the clouds of heaven.” In other words, as Wright puts it, Caiaphas will witness Jesus’s vindication in the events following Jesus’s death and in the judgment that will fall upon his regime and its central symbol. This explains his thoughts of himself as Messiah, what his intentions in the Temple and riddles surrounding it were, why it was so easy for the chief priests to arrest him as a rebel king and how Pilate came to crucify Jesus with the words “King of the Jews” written above his head. Finally, it helps us see why his disciples regarded him as Messiah after the resurrection. The Temple did not stand alone in it’s meaning- the riddles around it help us understand all that he was doing. Next week we will see what the deal is with the Last Supper!
The beginnings
Before we start our exegetical study through the Gospel of Mark, we have to discuss several ideals and concepts, starting with the very important question “What is Truth?”
How do we know that the Bible is true? Because it fits within both the Metaphysical and Epistemological systems of truth.
Ever since the early Christian church began to spread and its ideas began to confront the Roman world, thinkers and philosophers have been examining Christianity and its truth claims, trying to exploit it as a ridiculous superstition and a fraud. Let’s examine one of the greatest arguments against Christ.
During the 1920’s, a Nobel-Prize winning philosopher by the name of Bertrand Russell gave a lecture at a London club addressing Britain’s finest secular humanists. The lecture was titled “Why I Am Not a Christian,” and it turned the tides of the war between Christianity and Atheism even to this day.
In his lecture, Russell took a unique approach. While addressing the arguments against the existence of God like the preceding philosophers before him, Russell went where few dared to venture before: attacking Jesus himself. Using Jesus’ own words, he proves that Jesus is a false prophet, or seemingly so. Let’s reference Russell’s argument in Mark 13.
“Then he says: ‘There are some standing here which shall not taste death till the Son of Man come into his kingdom’; and there are a lot of places where it is quite clear that he believed his second coming would happen during the lifetime of many then living. That was the belief of his earlier followers, and it was the basis of a good deal of his moral teaching. When he said, ‘Take no thought for the morrow’, and things of that sort, it was very largely because he thought that the second coming was going to be very soon, and that all ordinary mundane affairs did not count. I have, as a matter of fact, known some Christians who did believe that the second coming was imminent. I knew a parson who frightened his congregation terribly by telling them that the second coming was imminent indeed, but they were much consoled when they found that he was planting trees in his garden. The early Christians did really believe it, and they did abstain from such things as planting trees in their gardens, because they did accept from Christ the belief that the second coming was imminent. In that respect clearly he was not so wise as some other people have been, and he was certainly not superlatively wise.”
The problem here is not what Jesus said is true or not, because the Gospel is true in both models of Metaphysical and Epistemological Truth. The problem here is a matter of interpretation. Either Bertrand Russell’s interpretation of Mark’s Gospel is true, or the contemporary church’s interpretation is true.
How do we interpret the Bible? Is it okay for us all to interpret the Bible from our own perspective? Does that correspond with the notion of Truth?
This is where the notion of Biblical Hermeneutics comes in…
Next week we will delve further into the practice and philosophies surrounding Hermeneutics, and how to read the Bible.
-Josh Estep October 2005
How do we know that the Bible is true? Because it fits within both the Metaphysical and Epistemological systems of truth.
Ever since the early Christian church began to spread and its ideas began to confront the Roman world, thinkers and philosophers have been examining Christianity and its truth claims, trying to exploit it as a ridiculous superstition and a fraud. Let’s examine one of the greatest arguments against Christ.
During the 1920’s, a Nobel-Prize winning philosopher by the name of Bertrand Russell gave a lecture at a London club addressing Britain’s finest secular humanists. The lecture was titled “Why I Am Not a Christian,” and it turned the tides of the war between Christianity and Atheism even to this day.
In his lecture, Russell took a unique approach. While addressing the arguments against the existence of God like the preceding philosophers before him, Russell went where few dared to venture before: attacking Jesus himself. Using Jesus’ own words, he proves that Jesus is a false prophet, or seemingly so. Let’s reference Russell’s argument in Mark 13.
“Then he says: ‘There are some standing here which shall not taste death till the Son of Man come into his kingdom’; and there are a lot of places where it is quite clear that he believed his second coming would happen during the lifetime of many then living. That was the belief of his earlier followers, and it was the basis of a good deal of his moral teaching. When he said, ‘Take no thought for the morrow’, and things of that sort, it was very largely because he thought that the second coming was going to be very soon, and that all ordinary mundane affairs did not count. I have, as a matter of fact, known some Christians who did believe that the second coming was imminent. I knew a parson who frightened his congregation terribly by telling them that the second coming was imminent indeed, but they were much consoled when they found that he was planting trees in his garden. The early Christians did really believe it, and they did abstain from such things as planting trees in their gardens, because they did accept from Christ the belief that the second coming was imminent. In that respect clearly he was not so wise as some other people have been, and he was certainly not superlatively wise.”
The problem here is not what Jesus said is true or not, because the Gospel is true in both models of Metaphysical and Epistemological Truth. The problem here is a matter of interpretation. Either Bertrand Russell’s interpretation of Mark’s Gospel is true, or the contemporary church’s interpretation is true.
How do we interpret the Bible? Is it okay for us all to interpret the Bible from our own perspective? Does that correspond with the notion of Truth?
This is where the notion of Biblical Hermeneutics comes in…
Next week we will delve further into the practice and philosophies surrounding Hermeneutics, and how to read the Bible.
-Josh Estep October 2005
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)